Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

Would Cynthia Nixon have been able to run a credible primary campaign against Cuomo without the Working Families Party?

in reply to this
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

You'd have to use excess death calculations to justify that equivalent. Over 20 years since 2003, the direct death toll in Iraq ia about 300K from "direct war related violence caused by the U.S., its allies, the Iraqi military and police, and opposition forces". watson.brown.edu/costsofwar/c... 1/

Iraqi Civilians | Costs of War

in reply to this
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

That's a much broader tally than US troops killing Iraqis in war, spread out over a much, much longer period, and would amounts to roughly half the proportion killed computing aggressively against a 2010 Iraq population for all of them. /fin

in reply to self
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

i think there's something a bit new here. the US killed people, more of them and sometimes just as wantonly, in Indochina and Korea, but the media environment was such that the US public only understood that slowly, only understood it fully long after the fact. 1/

in reply to this
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

one can believe that is the scale and brutality of US actions had been fully public in real time, they would have been politically impossible. 2/

in reply to self
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

during the Gulf and Middle East wars, the US was carefully attentive to perceptions of atrocity. again, of course there was atrocity anyway. there always is in war. 3/

in reply to self
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

but the scandals of the period, perhaps paradoxically, suggest a great deal of success. the biggest scandal of the Iraq War, the one that basically ended any possibility of "success" nation-building a democratic demonstration project, was Abu Ghraib. 4/

in reply to self
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

it was one facility, a relatively small number of perpetrators and victims, and it was a profound, earthshocking, incredible scandal that completely overthrew an epistemological deference, domestically, about how we were conducting the war and what our role was there. 5/

in reply to self
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

perhaps I am being unfair here, but my perception is that Abu-Ghraib-level torture and mistreatment of Palestinian detainees and worse is routine conduct in some Israeli facilities, and that this is something US publics basically know and now tolerate. 6/

in reply to self
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

(again, to distinguish, this is not waterboarding of high-level intelligence targets or the kind of ticking-time-bomb scenarios sold to the public to blur black and white views about torture. these are low-level, mass detainees.) 7/

in reply to self
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

there have been incidents not so far from Gaza that the US perpetrated — Mosul, Raqqa. but real time information about whatever degree of atrocity occurred was largely suppressed, and even ex post, one can distinguish their characters, no population was trapped. 8/

in reply to self
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

US publics have swallowed something quite different with Gaza and now Lebanon, a style of warfare promising to a certain degree to pay some attention to civilian life, but visibly offering a very high threshold for "proportionality", and intentionally eliminating civilian infrastructure. 9/

in reply to self
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

We've swallowed it with little more than a shrug. Which I understand given particulars about particular political realities, domestically and diplomatically. You could say it's only happening because the stars are particularly (mis)aligned. 10/

in reply to self
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

But it is happening. It's a kind of precedent. Hypocrisy was always at best the tribute vice pays to virtue, but I'd much rather we keep at least that tribute. A more "honest" embrace of atrocity we never completely eschewed does not strike me as a positive development going forward. /fin

in reply to self
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

A scary thing abt Gaza is, when considering future contingencies or policy changes and gaming out potential abuses, we'd clip a lower tails with remarks like, "It'd be too overt, too egregious, the public simply wouldn't tolerate it." After Gaza, that kind of implausibility claim seems implausible.

Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

That's an interesting point: Subnational legislations as "feeder leagues" for parties that compete to join the national legislature.

in reply to this
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

@leedrutman.bsky.social's suggestion of using single-transferable-vote multiwinner districts lets the number of winners serve as an elegant filter of parties with little support in a district, although if districts are v heterogenous, you could get some small delegations from locally popular parties

in reply to this
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

after reading Lee Drutman (and thinking about eg Israel), i think it's probably best to design a system so it gravitates to something like six parties, plus or minus.

in reply to this
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

oh, he's here! @leedrutman.bsky.social

in reply to self
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

(i think fusion voting would be a great reform, perhaps more plausible than others in the current US system. and i'm jealous of all those extra parties you have where you live.)

in reply to this
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

a democracy is a China shop. a billionaire is a bull.

Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

[new draft post] Rule-of-law is incompatible with a sharply polarized two-party system drafts.interfluidity.com/2024/10/21/r...

Rule-of-law is incompatible with a sharply polarized two-party system

Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

“We're handing so much money over to owners of prime residential or commercial land…of oil and gas fields, intellectual property and infrastructure…there isn't enough left to create…demand for dynamic sectors of the economy.” @chrisdillow.bsky.social stumblingandmumbling.typepad.com/stumbling_an...

Link Preview: 
Against Scooby Doo ideology: There's an unspoken and apparently unquestioned presumption at the centre of this government's economic policy. We saw three examples of it this week. The first came in Starmer's speech at an investme...

Against Scooby Doo ideology

Link Preview: Against Scooby Doo ideology: There's an unspoken and apparently unquestioned presumption at the centre of this government's economic policy. We saw three examples of it this week. The first came in Starmer's speech at an investme...
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

regardless of who becomes the next President, nothing is a Federal crime unless this Supreme Court agrees that it is.

Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

here’s to quicksand, my friend!

in reply to this
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

the main case people make for capitalism is that it gets incentives right to encourage people to act, to produce. but a capitalism under which the key to wealth is riding number-go-up by owning the right assets engenders very different incentives than to act, to produce.

Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

am i misreading the joke, or was Trump not the first major figure to allude to genital size during this campaign? www.cnn.com/2024/08/21/p...

Link Preview: 
Obama mocks Trump about his ‘weird obsession with crowd sizes’ | CNN Politics: At the Democratic National Convention, former President Barack Obama mocked former President Donald Trump and said he had a “weird obsession with crowd sizes.”

Obama mocks Trump about his ‘weird obsession with crowd sizes’ | CNN Politics

Link Preview: Obama mocks Trump about his ‘weird obsession with crowd sizes’ | CNN Politics: At the Democratic National Convention, former President Barack Obama mocked former President Donald Trump and said he had a “weird obsession with crowd sizes.”
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

slurring on about how all this is just a thimulaaaation. it might have been charming, in a sad way.

in reply to this
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

or the supreme court just legalizes his behavior ex post. no need to drag things out when you can clear the way for the next cycle.

in reply to this
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

It's arguably becoming a self-fulfilling prophesy.

in reply to this
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

maybe i am crediting him with too much, that he might game out a probability 0.5 alternative scenario in addition to his baseline scenario.

in reply to this
Steve Randy Waldman
@interfluidity.com

probably not. but even if Trump loses and the DOJ of course prosecutes, this may be the result. it follows pretty naturally from Citizen's United logic. unless of course we manage to reform the Court. we are a dead democracy barking unless and until we manage that.

in reply to this