@serge I’m glad to forgive you for being on edge. We all are these days I think, and “here” is rarely where we are at our best.

Israel and its relationship to questions of antisemitism are not Jews’ alone to adjudicate when the United States is using a particular view of those things to justify unprecedented actions against e.g. green card holders. @carolannie has every right, and perhaps even an obligation, to form her own view.