@BenRossTransit @Atrios I agree that there is lots of what gets called plagiarism that doesn’t merit the fuss. Reusing cookbook language in a methods suggestion, sure. But to the degree we maintain an idea of plagiarism at all, having someone else produce an entire creative work then publicly claim it as ones own surely qualifies, whatever arrangement they may have made with the true author. Even if their participation qualifies as coauthorship, it doesn’t justify hiding who wrote the text.